Well its the time of year again.
My faithful Garmin Fenix 3 HR has met her end.
Now i’ve lived 4 days without recording any swim and run activities. The pain of not seeing numbers hurts. Tangible pain. I’ve had thoughts of impulse buying the latest and greatest Fenix 5s already.
But I don’t want another $450 wasted again. Its time to review my needs vs wants of a multi sport watch Garmin makes.
As of June 2018, Garmin makes:
- Fenix 5 – $600
- Fenix 5x – $850 (amazon sells for cheaper :https://amzn.to/2NmGPhV)
- Fenix 5s – $600
- Fenix 3 HR – $380
- Fenix 3 – $250
- Fenix 2 – $180
- Original Fenix
- 935xt – $500
- 920xt – $200
- 910xt – $70
- 735xt – $340
- 645 – $500
- 635 – $450
- 630 – $400
- 620 – $130
- 235 – $280
- 230 – $260
- 225 – $150
- 220 – $100
- 35 – $250
- 15 – $100
- 10 – $60
- Vivoactive – $90
- Vivoactive 3 – $300 (you can find it on amazon here)
For Beginners, the bigger number means the more high up it is in the Garmin range. When you see “Fenix” Means you can get ready to spend a lot more money. Fenix watches are metal built, more durable, better battery and also more stylish. Perhaps you can say they are gamins luxury range of watches.
Basic Running Watches
They are the Garmin forerunner 10, forerunner 15, and forerunner 35.
These watches only have GPS function, so they are only able to tell you time, pace, distance (gps related settings) only.
Well, it might seem like thats enough but these watches forgo ANT+ platform where heart rate features/ Cadence/ Power functions are available.
But with the forerunner 35, it has wrist Heart rate so you don’t need a heart rate strap. Perfect for a quick and simple run.
But they are great as a second watch (when your main watch breaks), or if you just wanna run light.
Mid Tier Running Watches.
These typically start with a ‘2’ in front: 220, 225, 230, 235. And when you see a “5” at the back, means that the watch has an optical heart rate sensor. (No need a heart rate strap)
The difference between these and the basic running watches is that gps tend to load quicker, you get ANT+ and all its capabilities, customisable data screens and more.
They are a huge step up to the basic watches and for some, these watches are their Go-To watches to run in.
However, they come in a plastic build, prone to knocks and scratches, but makes it very light too.
Battery life is ample but not fantastic.
If you are looking to do intervals, these watches do not have a lap function. Which means you have to start and stop your watch and save the interval every time. (Or everything could be just one long run)
Its good for a watch to record lap times because when you upload it to Garmin connect or strava, you can see your times for each lap there.
And thats where the “600” range comes in.
Garmin’s Top Tier Running Watches
These are the 620, 630, 635, 645. They are fantastic watches for running. They track fast, accurate, light weight and all the capabilities you would want.
Including VO2 Max score, race predictions, Treadmill running, Lap function. And of course ANT+ with all its capabilities.
I know a triathlete who still uses a 620 and a heart rate monitor for all his run workouts. (He’s got an Edge 500 for bike and he does’t use a watch for swimming)
Buts thats exactly it- I need a watch while swimming. Pure swimmer may scoff at the level of professionalism. But in reality not every pool has a pool clock, and id much rather upload the data online so I could actually see numbers getting better. (not just by feel)
Thats why Ill go for a triathlon watch.
Garmin’s Triathlon Watches.
These are the 735xt, 910xt, 920xt, 935, and all the fenix series.
Only the 910xt, 920xt does NOT have a built in HR into the watch, so to get HR function, you’ll need a heart rate strap. I had the 910xt for years and unfortunately it died on me during a swim. It was everything I needed, but not wanted. Awesome watch.
Okay the difference between triathlon watches and running watches is obviously the triathlon feature. And not just swim, bike, run. You can customise the activities too. For example im only doing a Bike run, I can change the settings on my watch for the watch to transition to run without going out to the main menu.
So thats awesome when I do my Saturday Swim Run training.
Ive had the 735xt. It was perfect except had just enough battery life. I sold it and got the Fenix 3 HR. It was also perfect. HAHA but it died. And was double the weight of the 735xt too 😦
To be honest, if you are looking for a basic triathlon watch, go for the 735xt.
If you need better battery, go for everything else.
If you need a solid build, (the plastics on the 900 series are hard plastics) go for the fenix series. (Metal construction)
If you want light weight, DONT go for the fenix series.
If you want the all of the above, go for the 935!
Oh…. But the price…. 😥
Vivoactive Series
I had the original vivoactive. And now theres the new vivoactive 3.
This series to me is more of the “Those who want to live an active lifestyle, not as crazy as triathletes”
It has triathlon features too. But in my experience, the toned down buttons, simple design makes it harder to navigate through screens and it does not have a lap function.
But in fact, the vivoactive has probably more features than you would expect.
It may be something ill consider since the watch is rather stylish. (Because of a more lifestyle approach)
Back to the Drawing Board
OK, Now what features of a watch I definitely need?
- Triathlon feature – Upon pressing the lap button switches between sports.
- Swimming pool counting – To be able to count my laps accurately
- Treadmill running – The watch has accelerometers and whatever sensors that can track running on the treadmill
- Good Battery Life – Able to last a half ironman 5-6h recording with GPS
- Bluetooth – YES uploading without the ANT+ Dongle!
Features that are nice to have:
- VO2 Max Calculator – Always nice to see this number increasing
- Estimated Recovery – I find that its pretty accurate after Im finished with the workout
- Wrist Heart Rate – not as reliable as a heart rate strap. Sometimes im at zone 2 while sprinting. haha
- Separate Lap Button – My 910xt has this and it was a dream to run intervals with.
- Time of Day with SECONDS during activity mode – My Fenix 3 does not have it, so I need another watch to tell my rest intervals
- Light weight – the Fenix 3 was twice as heavy as the 735xt
However, I really want to spend only $200 to $300 on another watch.
Another alternative is that I could buy a running watch and forgo the swimming altogether & use the pool clock.
Im thinking of settling on the Fenix 3 (no HR) or the 920xt or the 735xt. Their prices are quite reasonable as well since they’ve been out in the market for quite a while already:
Fenix 3:Â https://amzn.to/2MM2Yor
920xt:Â https://amzn.to/2lSomgE
735:Â https://amzn.to/2z4vK1V
I hope this gave you a better understanding of what Garmin offers, I know its quite brief but I don’t want to put all the statistics over here.
Thanks for reading! What will your next Garmin watch be?